Opened in 2008 with nine tables inside the historic Edgewater Hotel by Kevin and Laurie Tarter, who were tired of driving to Winter Park or Disney for a nice dinner. Sold in December 2025 to the hotel's new owner, with the name, manager and chef staying on; the three-course dining room is billed as intimate.
Over 50 Orlando: Winter Garden
Historic downtown Winter Garden is the most walkable dining night in this guide, with serious tasting menus, a busy market, live music, pizza and patios along Plant Street.
A brewery founded inside Plant Street Market in 2014 after a ski trip to Colorado, sharing the historic market with about 20 local vendors. A family-friendly taproom by its own description, with a pet-friendly patio.
A Tremaine Street Italian restaurant making its dough, sauces and desserts in-house, with wood-fired pizza, pasta, a bar and sidewalk tables beside the Butterfly Sculpture Park.
Chef Ryan Freelove's seasonal modern American room in the Roper Garden Building, by the Garden Theatre's stage door, so dinner and a show is a real plan here. The walls show local artwork, and the patio faces the free city garage.
An eight-seat sushi bar inside Plant Street Market with a Bib Gourmand four years running. Nigiri comes on washi paper that guests fold into cranes for the paper crane centerpiece.
A small Plant Street wine bar and bistro with live music most open nights and scheduled afternoon tea events. It is a cozy choice when the point is to stay, listen and talk rather than rush through dinner.
This is a music venue. It is loud when a show is on.
A Plant Street kitchen and bar with brick-oven flatbreads, American comfort food, cocktails, indoor and outdoor seating, weekend brunch and room for groups. It is a flexible choice when a downtown walk needs an easy sit-down meal.